Humane ways to trap a mouse

Mouse Removal Tools & Traps

TDS Reader Contributors

Related Articles

Getting Rid of Field Mice

Ideas for Getting Rid of Mice

Humane Mouse Removal

Removing the Smarter Than Average Mouse

I have a Plymouth Voyager, and being handicapped, my motorized scooter is kept in there. My husband plugs it into the wall through a slight opening in the window of the Voyager. Unfortunately, a mouse (a very smart mouse, I might add) has moved into our Voyager. We bought a coffin-type catcher from Home Depot that closes behind the mouse as it enters to get the cheese. Well, this mouse got the cheese and got back out of his coffin! We went back to Home Depot and bought a sticky-type thing and put the cheese in the center. When we checked the next day, the cheese was gone and you could see the tiny footprints, but alas he got away.

We kept ketchup packets in the glove compartment and found them opened and licked clean! I don't want to kill the mouse. I just want it out! Does anyone have any ideas or suggestions for mouse removal tools or traps? I think it hides behind the glove compartment. It's at the point where I'm afraid to go into the car. On "warmer" days, we've left the car door open for 1/2 hour with no luck.
Ethel K.

Mouse Removal Tools

If using the "coffin" type traps, use peanut butter as bait and smear it on well where the bait goes. Not only do mice find it absolutely irresistible, unlike cheese, but also they can't just pick it up and run away with it. They have to get right into the trap to lick it up. I use a humane trap that tilts with the weight of the mouse and used bread as bait and had mice escaping until I tried peanut butter. Now, the mice get right into the trap and get caught like they should.

Sheets Chase Mice

I used scented fabric softener sheets, in our basement, which has done the trick.
W. B.

Mice, Mothballs and Kitties

Mice don't like mothballs. I know people who store their RV for the winter with mothballs in it to keep the mice out. This is not so nice for you.

I once had two mice in my condo. I borrowed a friend's cat for a night and found two dead but seemingly intact mice in the morning. No more problems. This would not meet your goal of not harming the mouse, but if the mouse chews wires in your van, you could be in danger.
Erin of Ontario, Canada

Peppermint Oil Did the Trick

I live in an apartment and have found that there are two ways that are really helpful and fragrant as well. The first is to use natural mint oil (not mint extract). I get peppermint oil from the health food store and sprinkle it around my apartment (try not to put down too much because the aroma can be overwhelming). Or try Downy fabric softener sheets. For some reason, Herman (yes, we named our furry friend) was not to fond of these smells, but we enjoyed them.

Call Animal Control for Advice

I would call the urban animal control center in your city. I had a similar problem with a resident squirrel in my engine. I used Pine Sol soaked rags, which the squirrel found most repugnant. It worked very well and the squirrel did not come back. I was given this advice through the city. They also have assorted traps they loan out.

Homemade Trap Help

Get a five-gallon bucket (often free at McDonalds if you ask). I got one at Home Depot recently for $1.25. Put some smelly cheese or peanut butter in the bucket.

Take a piece of cardboard or an old checkerboard to cover the top, and cut a hole in the center. About a 3-inch hole, any shape, should be fine. Either tape or weigh the top down.

Put this in the car with some means for the mouse to get to the top, but be sure it isn't going to tip over. Behind the seat would be a good choice. I've used it in the house with an old blanket for a ramp up. If the bait is smelly, they will go for it.

The mouse will jump and almost reach the top, but the cardboard will keep the mouse from getting out. You can then decide what to do with the mouse. I've released several, and none have come back.

Some Like It Hot… but Mice Don't

Mice hate cayenne pepper. Sprinkle the pepper generously throughout the car, within the engine compartment, in the glove compartment, under the seats, etc. After verifying that the mouse has left, just vacuum the pepper out and replace it with air freshener.

Remove the Food, Remove the Mouse

If you keep leaving cheese out for him, you will kill him. Contrary to the old wives' tale, cheese is not a "natural" food for mice, and is actually toxic to them. This would solve your problem of course, but if you claim that you don't want to kill him, different bait would be safer. The best thing I could suggest for getting him out of the car would be to remove any and all edible things, such as ketchup packets, crumbs, wrappers, etc. Clean the car out so that there is nothing to eat, and he will have no reason to stay.

Shop the web's most popular pest control store at

The Luck of the Irish

Here is a simple, cheap mouse removal tool. Place several bars of open Irish Spring soap throughout the van. Mice and rats cannot stand the smell. A friend has more than 20 cars on his property in various stages of restoration, and this is the method that he uses. Hanging them in empty orange bags might keep the bars from sliding all over the car, as well.
Maureen in MN

For the Discriminating Palate

When trying to get rid of mice, you may have to be creative in your bait. Look and see what the mouse has been eating. In Ethel's case, she knew the mouse was eating the ketchup from the ketchup packets, so she should bait the traps with ketchup. My cousin had a problem with mice once but couldn't seem to catch many using the old standby baits of cheese and peanut butter. She started looking at what the mice were feasting on in her kitchen and it turned out to be chocolate of all things. She began baiting the traps with leftover Easter chocolate candies and the mice flocked to the traps. After catching several dozen, she found that she could even just put chocolate syrup on the traps as bait and still catch mice. Using this method, she finally got rid of all of the mice. Incidently, she is a "clean freak" and "neat freak" and did not leave food laying around. The mice came after construction crews began clearing some adjacent wooded property for new home construction. Their home apparently was disturbed by the construction crews.

Take the Next Step:

  • Stop struggling to get ahead financially. Subscribe to our free weekly Surviving Tough Times newsletter aimed at helping you 'live better...for less'. Each issue features great ways to help you stretch your dollars and make the most of your resources. Subscribers get a copy of Are You Heading for Debt Trouble? A Simple Checklist And What You Can Do About It for FREE!
  • From bees to fleas and everything in between, The Dollar Stretcher's Frugal Pest Control Guide can help you save money battling bugs and other pests.

Share your thoughts about this article with the editor.

Stay Connected with TDS

Little Luxuries

to the Dollar Stretcher newsletter and get a copy
of our ebook
Little Luxuries:
130 Ways to Live Better...For Less
for FREE!

Your Email:

View the TDS Privacy Policy.

Debt Book