Could you trade for what you can't afford?

The Ins and Outs of Bartering

by Alex J. Coyne

Bartering is an ancient custom that's much older than money, but that doesn't mean money has replaced it by any means. When you think about modern bartering, there's no need to envision crazed, mangy-haired hippie-types in a dodgy neighborhood who are really trying to get rid of a stereo. Bartering is a completely legitimate business, and there are some great deals out there.

The Basics of Trading

I've traded a lot of things, including pool tables, amplifiers, speakers, guitar pedals, and books (to name just a few of them). Here's what you should think about when it comes to the trading business:

  • Always trade up. Get something similar or worth a little more than what you're giving away in terms of value, and when not, you should have the value made up by something extra (like more goods or cash). There's nothing worse than trading before you realize it's worth half of what you just gave away.
  • Research what you're giving up (and provide the interested buyer with accurate information) and research what you're looking to get in return. Research what the condition is like, what it is worth in cash terms, and what the current market demand is like. Also keep in mind what the market might be like in six months. I've gained cash by being right and lost cash by being wrong.
  • Be clear. Descriptive, accurate ads with attached images will get far more attention than misspelled ads with dark, blurry pictures. Does the item have any faults? List them. Is it a 1983 Stratocaster or a 1982? Check before you post.
  • Conduct your trade in public. Giving away your personal information or home address on the internet remains dangerous. Don't do it.
  • Be careful of couriers. When you have to ship items, make sure you're using a reputable courier and dealing with a reputable trader. Many bartering sites force you to create an account where people you have dealt with before can review your service. This helps cut down drastically on scammers.
  • Combinations of a trade and cash, where warranted, can work out great for both sides. Let's say you have half of what you need saved up for a laptop and you're not really using that console in the corner much these days. Put them together and you're much closer to your eventual goal.
  • Trade further up. Sometimes you have to trade several times, each a little more value, until you get to what you really want. This can be a great alternative when you don't have the cash. Just how successful can this be? Kyle MacDonald, one of the most famous cases, started off with a red paperclip and traded his way up to a house.
  • Avoid the hole of misjudgment. Trading is addictive, but some mistakes can be absolutely fatal. I've seen people trade real, $1000 guitars away for fakes. Always trade carefully.

The Best Bartering Sites

Besides the regular classified ad sites, there are a couple of reliable sites for trading. Most have every item you can possibly think of, and some are geared towards high-value items like houses and cars. You can even offer to trade with your skills.

Specifically for books, check out:

If you're bartering with (or for) textbooks, there's even an option called

Valuing Items

So, just what is it worth? When trading, you'll need to ask (and answer) that question. The cash value of an item is affected by the item's condition and the current market for the item. When trading, the market for the item is sometimes restricted to the market for that item with something you want for it. This sometimes leads to surprises and interim trades. I've been surprised by many trades, but luckily never in a horrible way!

Some items like antiques, high-value items, and commonly faked items need a little bit more thought in terms of authentication. Here are some questions to ask:

  • Is this the real thing? Check that it's consistent with what it claims to be. Ask on enthusiast forums. Check the serial number.
  • Is it original? Originals are often worth more than things with replacement parts.
  • What's the condition like? Specialist and vintage items are graded according to a specific scale. When trying to re-sell something, you want to know exactly what it is and what the condition is like.
  • Make sure accompanying paperwork is in order. When you're trading art, signed memorabilia, cars or houses, there's paperwork that goes with it. Authenticity certificates and pink slips are examples. Make sure it's all in order as it should be and keep in mind that paperwork can be faked, so always verify what you read.

Have you traded anything cool?

Reviewed January 2018

Take the Next Step:

Share your thoughts about this article with the editor.

Debt Book
Stay Connected with TDS

Do you struggle to get ahead financially?

Surviving Tough Times is a weekly newsletter aimed at helping you stretch your dollars and make the most of your resources.

Debt Checklist

And get a copy of Are You Heading for Debt Trouble?
A Simple Checklist and What You Can Do About It
for FREE!

Your Email:

View the TDS Privacy Policy.

Debt Book